Salmon-farm diseases were quickly reported
Dr. Gary Marty, Victoria Times Colonist, May 6, 2013
Re: “Fish farms allied with government, activists say,” May 5.
I am disappointed that important information was not included in the article. It quotes one of the emails that I sent last summer to a salmon-farm veterinarian asking: “May I have permission to disclose information from the medical records about the two Mainstream [IHN] outbreaks?” The email was one of many included in a recent 300-page freedom-of-information release to the Wilderness Committee.
The article neglects to say that, as a veterinarian, I am prohibited by my professional code of ethics from releasing to the public information contained in confidential medical records — unless I have permission; this is comparable to a doctor or a lawyer prohibited from releasing confidential records.
The article also neglects to say that the freedom-of-information release contains several examples where I asked the salmon-farm veterinarians for permission to release confidential medical information. Every time I asked, permission was granted.
Finally, the article does not say that, even before I asked the salmon farmers for permission to share information publicly, I had already reported suspicion of IHN to the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. The CFIA follows international guidelines for disease confirmation and reports all findings publicly.
The public can be assured that because I have a good relationship with the salmon farmers, the IHN outbreaks in 2012 on salmon farms were quickly diagnosed and reported to the CFIA and to the public.
Gary D. Marty
Fish pathologist
B.C. Ministry of Agriculture
BC fish farmers’ relations with government questioned
Canada: Environmental group goes fishing for ammunition to be used against the province’s salmon farmers, but finds little of value
Odd Grydeland, FishfarmingXpert, May 7, 2013
What the activists don’t realize is that the relationship between two veterinarians is not much different than that between two lawyers- client confidentiality is a basic principle of importance to both professions. And in a recent article in the Times Colonist, Judith Lavoie explains that fish farmers in British Columbia have already released more information about the health of their fish than what they are legally required to do;
In the ongoing skirmishes between salmon farmers and environmental groups, fish farmers appear to have a powerful ally in the provincial government, says Wilderness Committee campaigner Torrance Coste. A Wilderness Committee freedom-of-information request to the provincial Agriculture Ministry, asking for information on disease outbreaks on salmon farms between 2010 and 2012, produced 300 pages of emails and memos, many documenting communications strategies after diseases are discovered on farms.
Emails from Gary Marty, ministry fish pathologist at the Animal Health Centre, ask company veterinarians for the go-ahead to release specific information about the outbreaks to media. “May I have permission to disclose information from the medical records about the two Mainstream outbreaks,” says an email from Marty to Mainstream Canada veterinarian Peter McKenzie. “If you want to provide partial permission, let me know and I can work around that. Otherwise, I will stick to information provided in the press releases.” “I believe the release serves as good evidence of a very concerning relationship between the Ministry of Agriculture, who are supposed to be a neutral monitoring and oversight body, and the fish farming industry,” Coste said of the information found in the FOI.
However, Mary Ellen Walling, B.C. Salmon Farmers Association executive director, said the documents show a good working relationship between the industry and government, especially after infectious haematopoietic necrosis (IHN) was discovered at Grieg Seafood and Mainstream Canada farms. “I think those pages show a good level of co-operation, a high level of transparency and a lot of public outreach,” she said.
Coste, referring to the email from Marty, said he finds it alarming that ministry staff are asking for permission before releasing information that should be public. “This information pertains to disease outbreaks on private, open-net fish farms located in the ocean environment — a public entity,” he said.
“The presence of pathogens and viruses in the ocean and the discovery of these diseases by government scientists should always be public knowledge, and the fact that our scientists are seeking permission from industry to release this public knowledge is very worrisome.”
IHN, which is endemic in wild Pacific salmon but does not make them sick, can kill Atlantic salmon.
Walling said the request for permission was professional courtesy between veterinarians and the companies had already released information about the outbreaks. A statement from the agriculture ministry said the ministry works with the “federal government and aquaculture operators to monitor for all possible diseases and supports the implementation of a prompt, co-ordinated and science-based response when required.”
Fisheries and Oceans Canada is responsible for overall regulation of salmon farms. “The [agriculture] ministry has no statutory authority to compel samples from fish farms for diagnostic analysis. All submissions from the farms for diagnostic testing are voluntary,” says the ministry statement.
