Comment posted by Wescoastfishfarmer
Re: COLUMN: Salmon mystery needs a complete answer
Jeff Nagel, Black Press, Oct. 15, 2011
I see a pattern Alexandra.
A pattern consisting of you using weak correlations, combined with assumptions and bolstered by misinformation, to pursue your singleminded vendetta against the aquaculture industry.
Your self-righteousness and incredible arrogance astound me.
I watched you at the Cohen Commission state your case, and the impression I was left with was that you feel only you can see the truth; and anyone who does not join your crusade is either in the pocket of industry, or not intelligent enough to comprehend it.
Your disregard for Canadian law, the people of BC (Who you do NOT represent) and scientific method are the only obvious things for people to take away from this campaign of yours.
You are at the head of an activist movement which draws in people using fear and over-simplified, "connect-the-dots to get your predetermined result" science.
You are the 1%, not the 99% in this case.
And I thank my lucky stars for that.
Here is the comment posted by Alexandra Morton, Westcoastfishfarmer responded to:
Can anyone just look at the evidence and stop avoiding the obvious? The Fraser sockeye began declining exactly when salmon farms were placed on their migration routes. The runs that do not pass salmon farms have been thriving. Salmon Leukemia was reported in the Chinook salmon farms when they were placed on the sockeye migration route in 1990, when the Chinook farms were removed in 2007, the first sockeye run to go to sea since 1990 without exposure to these farms returned in 2010 and completely reversed the decline! A DFO scientist reports the sockeye are dying of a virus that looks like Salmon Leukemia and DFO takes away her funding, restricts her participation in meetings and wont let her talk to media. On top of this is the 1,100 symptoms of the deadly contagious ISA virus in Atlantic salmon. If people don't see a pattern here - I can't hep you.
Here is the Column that generated the Comments:
COLUMN: Salmon mystery needs a complete answer
Jeff Nagel, Black Press, Oct. 15, 2011
The battle of the scientists is over. More than 170 witnesses testified. Nearly 2,000 reports and documents were entered as evidence.
Now, the Cohen Commission is preparing to decide why the Fraser River’s sockeye salmon have been in a dangerous downward spiral.
Opponents of net-pen aquaculture have relentlessly spun the hearings as an open-shut case against salmon farms and stepped up campaigns to shut them down.
It’s not quite that simple.
Duelling researchers gave contradictory evidence on whether diseases or parasites from fish farms may be killing off wild sockeye.
That doesn’t mean fish farms aren’t bad for salmon.
The farms may, as critics claim, act as a breeding ground for pathogens, transmitting them to passing wild salmon at a critically vulnerable stage in their migration.
Much of the evidence before the inquiry, however, points to multiple different culprits, from ocean predators to changing water temperatures.
The commission has also looked at everything from urban sewage and industrial pollution along the lower Fraser to the impacts of logging and mining upriver.
A death-by-a-thousand-cuts verdict would admittedly be less satisfying than simply lynching one perceived bogeyman – one that we could definitely do something about.
But B.C. needs the most complete answer to this fishy mystery it can get.
It would be tragic if an eco-war succeeds in stamping out fish farms, only to see B.C.’s wild sockeye continue to decline because we weren’t vigilant enough in uncovering other threats and trying to address them.
Inquiry head Judge Bruce Cohen will hear final submissions from all sides in November before preparing his final report, due by next June.
As the inquiry moves into its final phase, it’s important to remember that the loss of B.C.’s wild sockeye stocks would have far-reaching repercussions beyond our dining choices.
With the sockeye may go many of the orcas, bears, birds and even freshwater fish in parts of B.C.
That’s because salmon are, in many ways, the lifeblood of our watersheds.
They act like a pipeline, bringing ocean nutrients far upstream.
Wildlife from tiny insects to the biggest predators feast on their spawned-out carcasses and even trees are fertilized.
Research has proven how salmon act as an extension of the forest’s root system, allowing the trees to draw nourishment not just from the immediate soil, but from the krill of the North Pacific.
The loss of wild salmon, some people fear, may loosen habitat-protection laws, opening B.C. not just to more fish farms and hatcheries, but hydro dams, offshore oil drilling and more industrial pollution.
For First Nations, whose heritage, culture, traditional diet and social customs are so deeply interwoven with the salmon, their loss is unfathomable.
Even if Judge Cohen fails to come up with a single suspect, we need his best assessment of what’s gone wrong and how we can keep this marvel of nature for generations to come.
